LAKE ERIE LEAGUE (Current)
- Bedford Bearcats (1998-Present)
- Lorain Titans (2010- Present)
- Maple Heights Mustangs (1998- Present)
- Shaw Cardinals (1928- Present)
- Warrensville Heights Tigers (1993- Present, [Football 1993-2014, 2016- Present])
- Garfield Heights Bulldogs (1968-2007 & 2019 – Present to Northeast Ohio [Football 1968-86, 1993- 2007], Independent 2015-2019)
FORMER MEMBERS
- Elyria Pioneers (1923–54, to Buckeye Conference. 1997-2003, to Pioneer)
- Lakewood Rangers (1923-2007, to Northeast Ohio)
- Lorain Steelmen (1923–54, to Buckeye Conference)
- Rocky River Pirates (1923–37, to Southwestern)
- Parma Redmen (1951-2003, to Pioneer)
- Brush Arcs (1962–75, to Greater Cleveland)
- Valley Forge Patriots (1962-2003, to Pioneer)
- Normandy Invaders (1968-2003, to Pioneer)
- Berea Braves (1975–79, to Pioneer)
- Midpark Meteors (1975–79, to Pioneer)
- Mentor Cardinals (1993-2011, to Northeast Ohio)
- Euclid Panthers (1998-2015, to Greater Cleveland)
- Admiral King Admirals (2002–10, consolidated into Lorain High)
- Southview Saints (2002–10, consolidated into Lorain High)
- Warren G. Harding Raiders (2010-2013, to All-American, football through 2014 season)
- Lutheran East Falcons (2017-2019)
- Cleveland Heights Tigers (1928-Present)
- Shaker Heights Red Raiders (1923-2012 & 2021-2023, to Northeast Ohio 2012-2015, to Greater Cleveland Conference 2015-2020)